西方马克思主义学者关于资本主义起源的研究述评

Translated title of the contribution: A Review of Studies in the Origin of Capitalism by Western Marxist

李 民圣

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

37 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The origin of capitalism has been an issue debated among Marxist for a long time. Because of inconsistent views on this issue from Marx himself, there are great differences when analyzing this problem among western Marxist. One is the so-called orthodox Marxist, like Dobb, Brenner and so on, concerns on the changes of the class relations within society; another one is the neo-Smithian Marxism, like Sweezy, Wallerstein and so on, believes the external factors, for example trade and the social division of labor, are the primary force; addition, Anderson is proposed to focus on changes in the field of politics. While the studies by Western Marxist inherited and developed Marx's theories and views, there is also defect of ignoring study on the force of product.
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)161-173
Number of pages13
JournalJournal of Economics of Shanghai School
Volume13
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

neo-Marxism
division of labor
capitalist society
politics
time
Society

Keywords

  • Marxist
  • The Origin of Capitalism
  • Trade
  • Class

Cite this

西方马克思主义学者关于资本主义起源的研究述评. / 李民圣.

In: Journal of Economics of Shanghai School, Vol. 13, No. 2, 2015, p. 161-173.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{406139227de64d749965f756c85b90b6,
title = "西方马克思主义学者关于资本主义起源的研究述评",
abstract = "资本主义起源问题是马克思主义学界长期争论的话题。由于马克思本人在此问题上的观点前后不一,导致西方马克思主义者内部在分析该问题时出现了较大的分歧。一种是以多布、布伦纳等所谓正统马克思主义者,关注社会内部的阶级关系变化;另一种是以斯威齐、沃勒斯坦等人所谓新斯密一马克思主义者,认为贸易和社会分工等外因是起源的推动力;此外,安德森则提出了要关注政治领域的变化。西方马克思主义者的研究既继承和发展了马克思的理论和观点,但也存在着忽视对生产力因素研究的缺陷。",
keywords = "Marxist , The Origin of Capitalism, Trade, Class, 马克思主义, 阶级 , 贸易 , 资本主义起源",
author = "民圣 李",
year = "2015",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "13",
pages = "161--173",
journal = "Journal of Economics of Shanghai School",
publisher = "上海财经大学海派经济学研究中心",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - 西方马克思主义学者关于资本主义起源的研究述评

AU - 李, 民圣

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - 资本主义起源问题是马克思主义学界长期争论的话题。由于马克思本人在此问题上的观点前后不一,导致西方马克思主义者内部在分析该问题时出现了较大的分歧。一种是以多布、布伦纳等所谓正统马克思主义者,关注社会内部的阶级关系变化;另一种是以斯威齐、沃勒斯坦等人所谓新斯密一马克思主义者,认为贸易和社会分工等外因是起源的推动力;此外,安德森则提出了要关注政治领域的变化。西方马克思主义者的研究既继承和发展了马克思的理论和观点,但也存在着忽视对生产力因素研究的缺陷。

AB - 资本主义起源问题是马克思主义学界长期争论的话题。由于马克思本人在此问题上的观点前后不一,导致西方马克思主义者内部在分析该问题时出现了较大的分歧。一种是以多布、布伦纳等所谓正统马克思主义者,关注社会内部的阶级关系变化;另一种是以斯威齐、沃勒斯坦等人所谓新斯密一马克思主义者,认为贸易和社会分工等外因是起源的推动力;此外,安德森则提出了要关注政治领域的变化。西方马克思主义者的研究既继承和发展了马克思的理论和观点,但也存在着忽视对生产力因素研究的缺陷。

KW - Marxist

KW - The Origin of Capitalism

KW - Trade

KW - Class

KW - 马克思主义

KW - 阶级

KW - 贸易

KW - 资本主义起源

M3 - 文章

VL - 13

SP - 161

EP - 173

JO - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

JF - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

IS - 2

ER -