广义价值论批判

与蔡继明教授商榷

Translated title of the contribution: Criticism on the General Theory of Value: A Discussion with Prof. Cai Jiming

岳 宏志, 寇 雅玲

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

On the basis of analyzing the General Theory of Value Determination with Two-Sector Model and the General Theory of Value Determination with N-Sector Model, this article holds that neither of the two theories conforms to the basic economic reality. On the contrary, they go against normal logical reasoning, thus are disqualified to be the so-called Fourth System of the Theory of Value, the first three being the Labor Theory of Value, the Neo一classical Theory of Value and the Sraffian Theory of Value. The article points out the arbitrariness and subjectivity in the construction of the General Theory of Value.
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)135-152
Number of pages18
JournalJournal of Economics of Shanghai School
Volume3
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2005
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Criticism
Theory of Value
General Theory
Arbitrariness
Labor Theory of Value
Economics
Subjectivity
Logic

Keywords

  • opportunity cost
  • comparative advantage
  • composed commodities
  • comparative cost
  • General Theory of Value

Cite this

广义价值论批判 : 与蔡继明教授商榷. / 岳宏志; 寇雅玲.

In: Journal of Economics of Shanghai School, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2005, p. 135-152.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

岳宏志 & 寇雅玲 2005, '广义价值论批判: 与蔡继明教授商榷', Journal of Economics of Shanghai School, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 135-152.
岳宏志 ; 寇雅玲. / 广义价值论批判 : 与蔡继明教授商榷. In: Journal of Economics of Shanghai School. 2005 ; Vol. 3, No. 1. pp. 135-152.
@article{d2a0905b84564f1bbf7ef913c68a6787,
title = "广义价值论批判: 与蔡继明教授商榷",
abstract = "通过分析广义价值决定理论的两部门模型和N部门模型,本文认为无论是广义价值论的两部门模型还是广义价值论的N部门模型,都不仅不符合基本的经济现实,而且违背了正常的逻辑推理,根本没有资格成为继劳动价值论、新古典价值论和斯拉法价值论之后的所谓第四大价值理论体系。本文揭示了广义价值论构建过程中逻辑推理的随意性和主观性。",
keywords = "opportunity cost, comparative advantage, composed commodities, comparative cost, General Theory of Value, 机会成本, 比较利益, 合成商品, 比较成本, 广义价值",
author = "宏志 岳 and 雅玲 寇",
year = "2005",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "3",
pages = "135--152",
journal = "Journal of Economics of Shanghai School",
publisher = "上海财经大学海派经济学研究中心",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - 广义价值论批判

T2 - 与蔡继明教授商榷

AU - 岳, 宏志

AU - 寇, 雅玲

PY - 2005

Y1 - 2005

N2 - 通过分析广义价值决定理论的两部门模型和N部门模型,本文认为无论是广义价值论的两部门模型还是广义价值论的N部门模型,都不仅不符合基本的经济现实,而且违背了正常的逻辑推理,根本没有资格成为继劳动价值论、新古典价值论和斯拉法价值论之后的所谓第四大价值理论体系。本文揭示了广义价值论构建过程中逻辑推理的随意性和主观性。

AB - 通过分析广义价值决定理论的两部门模型和N部门模型,本文认为无论是广义价值论的两部门模型还是广义价值论的N部门模型,都不仅不符合基本的经济现实,而且违背了正常的逻辑推理,根本没有资格成为继劳动价值论、新古典价值论和斯拉法价值论之后的所谓第四大价值理论体系。本文揭示了广义价值论构建过程中逻辑推理的随意性和主观性。

KW - opportunity cost

KW - comparative advantage

KW - composed commodities

KW - comparative cost

KW - General Theory of Value

KW - 机会成本

KW - 比较利益

KW - 合成商品

KW - 比较成本

KW - 广义价值

M3 - 文章

VL - 3

SP - 135

EP - 152

JO - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

JF - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

IS - 1

ER -