“《21世纪资本论》之谜”何以可能

形而上学方法论批判的视角

Translated title of the contribution: How "The Mystery of Capital in the 21st Century"to be Possible: A Critical Perspective of the Methodology of Metaphysics

宁 殿霞

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The research conclusion r>g of Piketty's Capital in the 21st Century is obtained through the empirical data, which objectively proved Marx's law of falling rate of profit. But subjectively, he takes the profit margin of the development of the productive forces as the isolated capital return rate, while understands the capital accumulation as the principle of Infinite accumulation stillness, he considers the global economic growth in the world as a whole as One一sided Countries hold equal capital positions. It makes him to take from the subjective negation of Marx's law of falling rate of profit so that forms "The Mystery of Capital in the 21st Century". In fact, Pikett}s objective results does not conflict with MarXS theory, but his subjective judgment goes to the opposite. Piketty uses formal logic to under- stand the reality and Marx's theory. His results are very meaningful, but he takes the concept of Marx's dialectics as the concept of metaphysics, which must be asymmetric.
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)93-102
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Economics of Shanghai School
Volume13
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Karl Marx
Critical perspective
Metaphysics
Methodology
Rate of profit
Profit margin
Economic growth
Empirical data
Dialectics
Logic
Capital accumulation

Keywords

  • Capital in the 21st Century
  • Metaphysics
  • Return on Capital
  • Falling Rate of Profit

Cite this

“《21世纪资本论》之谜”何以可能 : 形而上学方法论批判的视角. / 宁殿霞.

In: Journal of Economics of Shanghai School, Vol. 13, No. 4, 2015, p. 93-102.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e3fe0ceeba1c44bb8c998e24769ef3b7,
title = "“《21世纪资本论》之谜”何以可能: 形而上学方法论批判的视角",
abstract = "皮凯蒂的《21世纪资本论》通过实证的历史数据得出r>g的研究结论,这在客观上证明了马克思的利润率下降规律,但是主观上他却把蕴含着生产力发展的利润率理解为孤立的资本收益率、把运动的资本积累理解为静止的无限积累原则、把全球整体经济增长中的互动理解为片面的各国持有资本头寸相等。这导致他从主观上旗帜鲜明地否定了马克思的利润率下降规律,从而构成了{"}《21世纪资本论》之谜{"}。其实,皮凯蒂的客观研究结果与马克思的理论并不冲突,只是他的主观判断走向了反面。造成这一迷局的根本原因是他用形式逻辑理解他自己面对的现实和马克思的理论。他遵循形式逻辑得出的研究结果也是非常有意义的,但他用形而上学的概念对接马克思的辩证法...",
keywords = "Capital in the 21st Century, Metaphysics, Return on Capital, Falling Rate of Profit, 《21世纪资本论》, 形而上学, 资本收益率, 利润率下降",
author = "殿霞 宁",
year = "2015",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "13",
pages = "93--102",
journal = "Journal of Economics of Shanghai School",
publisher = "上海财经大学海派经济学研究中心",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - “《21世纪资本论》之谜”何以可能

T2 - 形而上学方法论批判的视角

AU - 宁, 殿霞

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - 皮凯蒂的《21世纪资本论》通过实证的历史数据得出r>g的研究结论,这在客观上证明了马克思的利润率下降规律,但是主观上他却把蕴含着生产力发展的利润率理解为孤立的资本收益率、把运动的资本积累理解为静止的无限积累原则、把全球整体经济增长中的互动理解为片面的各国持有资本头寸相等。这导致他从主观上旗帜鲜明地否定了马克思的利润率下降规律,从而构成了"《21世纪资本论》之谜"。其实,皮凯蒂的客观研究结果与马克思的理论并不冲突,只是他的主观判断走向了反面。造成这一迷局的根本原因是他用形式逻辑理解他自己面对的现实和马克思的理论。他遵循形式逻辑得出的研究结果也是非常有意义的,但他用形而上学的概念对接马克思的辩证法...

AB - 皮凯蒂的《21世纪资本论》通过实证的历史数据得出r>g的研究结论,这在客观上证明了马克思的利润率下降规律,但是主观上他却把蕴含着生产力发展的利润率理解为孤立的资本收益率、把运动的资本积累理解为静止的无限积累原则、把全球整体经济增长中的互动理解为片面的各国持有资本头寸相等。这导致他从主观上旗帜鲜明地否定了马克思的利润率下降规律,从而构成了"《21世纪资本论》之谜"。其实,皮凯蒂的客观研究结果与马克思的理论并不冲突,只是他的主观判断走向了反面。造成这一迷局的根本原因是他用形式逻辑理解他自己面对的现实和马克思的理论。他遵循形式逻辑得出的研究结果也是非常有意义的,但他用形而上学的概念对接马克思的辩证法...

KW - Capital in the 21st Century

KW - Metaphysics

KW - Return on Capital

KW - Falling Rate of Profit

KW - 《21世纪资本论》

KW - 形而上学

KW - 资本收益率

KW - 利润率下降

M3 - 文章

VL - 13

SP - 93

EP - 102

JO - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

JF - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

IS - 4

ER -