评丁堡骏关于转形问题的解法

兼与岳宏志、朱奎等商榷

Translated title of the contribution: On the Solution to Transformation Problems Adopted by Ding Bao一un: A Discuss with Yue Hong-zhi and Zhu Kui

刘 艳龙

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

"The Study of Transformation Problems" written by Ding 13ao-jun develops the Marx's transformation analysis, scientifically solves the transformation problems after the elements are put into production, and expands Marx's models of values transformation. Yue Hong-zhi and Zhu Kui wrote articles successively to put forward some questions and bring up the modified models. This article aims to prove that the models adopted by Yue and Zhu are influenced by Ding, and in essence, are another version of Ding's model, and that there're some distortion and misunderstanding about Ding's model in the articles written by Yue and Zhu. Moreover, this article supplements the two equal relation proved by Ding's model.
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)153-164
Number of pages12
JournalJournal of Economics of Shanghai School
Volume3
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2005
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Karl Marx
Supplements
Essence
Misunderstanding

Keywords

  • values
  • production prices
  • transformation problems
  • expanded models of values transformation

Cite this

评丁堡骏关于转形问题的解法 : 兼与岳宏志、朱奎等商榷. / 刘艳龙.

In: Journal of Economics of Shanghai School, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2005, p. 153-164.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{d7b524e2c37e433b8e7783335499559c,
title = "评丁堡骏关于转形问题的解法: 兼与岳宏志、朱奎等商榷",
abstract = "丁堡骏的《转形问题研究》一文,完善和发展了马克思的转形分析,科学地解答了要素投入生产价格化后转形问题,创立了扩大的马克思价值转化模型。岳宏志、朱奎等先后撰文对丁氏扩大的马克思价值转化模型进行质疑并提出了修正模型。本文一方面证明岳、朱模型是受丁氏模型的影响而建立起来的,就其本质方面来讲,岳、朱模型就是丁氏模型,另一方面又证明岳、朱模型对丁氏模型的主要方面存在着严重的误解和曲解。本文还就运用丁氏模型证明两个等量关系进行了补充说明。",
keywords = "values , production prices, transformation problems, expanded models of values transformation, 价值, 生产价格, “转形问题”, 扩大的价值转化模型",
author = "艳龙 刘",
year = "2005",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "3",
pages = "153--164",
journal = "Journal of Economics of Shanghai School",
publisher = "上海财经大学海派经济学研究中心",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - 评丁堡骏关于转形问题的解法

T2 - 兼与岳宏志、朱奎等商榷

AU - 刘, 艳龙

PY - 2005

Y1 - 2005

N2 - 丁堡骏的《转形问题研究》一文,完善和发展了马克思的转形分析,科学地解答了要素投入生产价格化后转形问题,创立了扩大的马克思价值转化模型。岳宏志、朱奎等先后撰文对丁氏扩大的马克思价值转化模型进行质疑并提出了修正模型。本文一方面证明岳、朱模型是受丁氏模型的影响而建立起来的,就其本质方面来讲,岳、朱模型就是丁氏模型,另一方面又证明岳、朱模型对丁氏模型的主要方面存在着严重的误解和曲解。本文还就运用丁氏模型证明两个等量关系进行了补充说明。

AB - 丁堡骏的《转形问题研究》一文,完善和发展了马克思的转形分析,科学地解答了要素投入生产价格化后转形问题,创立了扩大的马克思价值转化模型。岳宏志、朱奎等先后撰文对丁氏扩大的马克思价值转化模型进行质疑并提出了修正模型。本文一方面证明岳、朱模型是受丁氏模型的影响而建立起来的,就其本质方面来讲,岳、朱模型就是丁氏模型,另一方面又证明岳、朱模型对丁氏模型的主要方面存在着严重的误解和曲解。本文还就运用丁氏模型证明两个等量关系进行了补充说明。

KW - values

KW - production prices

KW - transformation problems

KW - expanded models of values transformation

KW - 价值

KW - 生产价格

KW - “转形问题”

KW - 扩大的价值转化模型

M3 - 文章

VL - 3

SP - 153

EP - 164

JO - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

JF - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

IS - 1

ER -