对张忠任转形研究批评的反批评

与岳宏志先生和寇雅玲女士商榷

Translated title of the contribution: Put forward instead of Criticize upon Criticismon Zhang Zhong-ren's Research of the Transformation Problem: Discuss with Mr. Yue Hong-zhi and Ms. Kou Ya-ling

张 忠任

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

A Mathematical Proof on Marzist Transformation Theory-Some Remarks on Mr. ZhangZhong-ren's Research Method of Transformation Problem written by Mr. Yue Hong-zhi and Ms. Kou Ya-ling has been published in QUANTITIVE AND TECHNICAL ECONOMICS VoL 22 No. 6 2005. However, this article, theoretically, has confused the logical relationship between the value and the price of production, and inverts causal relationship of the constraint condition and the objective function in mathematics. On the base of comprehensively analyzing the mistakes made by Mr. Yue Hong-zhi and Ms. Kou Ya-ling's, this paper not only replies in details the questions put forward by them, but also makes clear Zhang Zhong-ren's transformation model validity and clarifies some fuzzy ideas, then further deepens the understanding of the theory concerning the transformation problem.
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)122-129
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of Economics of Shanghai School
Volume4
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

research method
mathematics
economics
Values

Keywords

  • causal relation
  • value
  • price of production
  • deviation rate
  • restraint condition

Cite this

对张忠任转形研究批评的反批评 : 与岳宏志先生和寇雅玲女士商榷. / 张忠任.

In: Journal of Economics of Shanghai School, Vol. 4, No. 1, 2006, p. 122-129.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{393a5499603f4a8689e47aeeca12b944,
title = "对张忠任转形研究批评的反批评: 与岳宏志先生和寇雅玲女士商榷",
abstract = "《数量经济与技术经济研究》2005年第6期发表了岳宏志和寇雅玲关于《马克思转形理论的一个数理证明——兼评张忠任先生关于转形问题的研究》一文(以下简称《岳文》)。但是,该文在理论上混淆了价值和生产价格的逻辑关系,在数学上颠倒了约束条件和目标函数的因果关系。本文在全面分析《岳文》的错误的基础上,一一回答了该文所提出的问题,明确了张忠任转形模型的有效性,澄清了一些模糊观念,并进一步深化了对转形问题的理论认识。",
keywords = "causal relation, value, price of production, deviation rate, restraint condition, 因果关系, 价值, 生产价格, 偏离率, 约束条件",
author = "忠任 张",
year = "2006",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "4",
pages = "122--129",
journal = "Journal of Economics of Shanghai School",
publisher = "上海财经大学海派经济学研究中心",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - 对张忠任转形研究批评的反批评

T2 - 与岳宏志先生和寇雅玲女士商榷

AU - 张, 忠任

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - 《数量经济与技术经济研究》2005年第6期发表了岳宏志和寇雅玲关于《马克思转形理论的一个数理证明——兼评张忠任先生关于转形问题的研究》一文(以下简称《岳文》)。但是,该文在理论上混淆了价值和生产价格的逻辑关系,在数学上颠倒了约束条件和目标函数的因果关系。本文在全面分析《岳文》的错误的基础上,一一回答了该文所提出的问题,明确了张忠任转形模型的有效性,澄清了一些模糊观念,并进一步深化了对转形问题的理论认识。

AB - 《数量经济与技术经济研究》2005年第6期发表了岳宏志和寇雅玲关于《马克思转形理论的一个数理证明——兼评张忠任先生关于转形问题的研究》一文(以下简称《岳文》)。但是,该文在理论上混淆了价值和生产价格的逻辑关系,在数学上颠倒了约束条件和目标函数的因果关系。本文在全面分析《岳文》的错误的基础上,一一回答了该文所提出的问题,明确了张忠任转形模型的有效性,澄清了一些模糊观念,并进一步深化了对转形问题的理论认识。

KW - causal relation

KW - value

KW - price of production

KW - deviation rate

KW - restraint condition

KW - 因果关系

KW - 价值

KW - 生产价格

KW - 偏离率

KW - 约束条件

M3 - 文章

VL - 4

SP - 122

EP - 129

JO - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

JF - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

IS - 1

ER -