再论“五种社会形态理论”问题: 答段忠桥教授的辩文和赵家祥教授的商榷

Translated title of the contribution: Rethinking the Problem of“the Five Theories of Social Modality": Reply to the Debate of Prof. Duan Zhong-qiao and Discuss with Prof. Zhao Jia-xiang

奚 兆永

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper rediscusses the problem of "The Theory of Five Social Formations",as a reply to Prof. Duan Zhongqiao's critical comment and Prof. Zhao Jiaxiang’s discussion. The article stresses that it is not enough to just understand "Preface" according to "Draft",and then proposes the corresponding argument. Simultaneously, this paper elaborates two different kinds of "Three Social Formations" and the relation between them and "Five Social Formations". The article also discusses some methodology significant problems such as the inorder alternation and coexistence of production methods, and the relationship between philosophy of history and the historical environment.
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)157-181
Number of pages25
JournalJournal of Economics of Shanghai School
Volume5
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 2007
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Modality
Draft
Coexistence
Methodology
Alternation
Philosophy of History

Keywords

  • five social formations
  • three social formations
  • inorder alternation coexistence
  • philosophy of history

Cite this

再论“五种社会形态理论”问题 : 答段忠桥教授的辩文和赵家祥教授的商榷. / 奚兆永.

In: Journal of Economics of Shanghai School, Vol. 5, No. 3, 2007, p. 157-181.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{45b4c9ba76794142b39b04d878e03ada,
title = "再论“五种社会形态理论”问题: 答段忠桥教授的辩文和赵家祥教授的商榷",
abstract = "本文再次讨论了{"}五种社会形态理论{"}问题,对段忠桥教授的答辩和赵家祥教授的商榷做出了回应。文章强调,不能只是从《草稿》来理解《序言》,并进一步提出相应的论据;同时论述两种不同的{"}三形态论{"}及其与{"}五形态论{"}的关系。文章还讨论生产方式的依次交替和同时并存,历史哲学和历史环境的关系等具有方法论意义的问题。",
keywords = "five social formations, three social formations, inorder alternation coexistence, philosophy of history, 五种社会形态, 三大社会形态, 依次交替, 同时并存, 历史哲学",
author = "兆永 奚",
year = "2007",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "5",
pages = "157--181",
journal = "Journal of Economics of Shanghai School",
publisher = "上海财经大学海派经济学研究中心",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - 再论“五种社会形态理论”问题

T2 - 答段忠桥教授的辩文和赵家祥教授的商榷

AU - 奚, 兆永

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - 本文再次讨论了"五种社会形态理论"问题,对段忠桥教授的答辩和赵家祥教授的商榷做出了回应。文章强调,不能只是从《草稿》来理解《序言》,并进一步提出相应的论据;同时论述两种不同的"三形态论"及其与"五形态论"的关系。文章还讨论生产方式的依次交替和同时并存,历史哲学和历史环境的关系等具有方法论意义的问题。

AB - 本文再次讨论了"五种社会形态理论"问题,对段忠桥教授的答辩和赵家祥教授的商榷做出了回应。文章强调,不能只是从《草稿》来理解《序言》,并进一步提出相应的论据;同时论述两种不同的"三形态论"及其与"五形态论"的关系。文章还讨论生产方式的依次交替和同时并存,历史哲学和历史环境的关系等具有方法论意义的问题。

KW - five social formations

KW - three social formations

KW - inorder alternation coexistence

KW - philosophy of history

KW - 五种社会形态

KW - 三大社会形态

KW - 依次交替

KW - 同时并存

KW - 历史哲学

M3 - 文章

VL - 5

SP - 157

EP - 181

JO - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

JF - Journal of Economics of Shanghai School

IS - 3

ER -